National Highways speed enforcement camera issue
Update on a technical issue affecting some speed enforcement cameras on England’s motorways.
At the end of last year, my predecessor informed the House that National Highways had identified an anomaly affecting the interaction between some variable speed cameras and signage on the strategic road network in England, originating from the upgrade and installation of the camera system beginning in 2019 under the previous government.
This meant that, on very rare occasions, drivers were not given sufficient time to respond to a change in speed limit or were detected as speeding when the variable speed limit had changed.
This error affected cameras on around 0.2% of all roads in England, and immediate steps were taken to prevent any erroneous enforcement and redress any historic enforcement that was incorrect. Everyone who we have been able to identify and contact has been offered redress. We will continue to provide redress to eligible individuals, where identified.
Since the anomaly was identified, National Highways has been working in collaboration with the Home Office to carry out extensive technical and operational testing of the relevant camera and enforcement systems. These investigations have brought to light a potential further issue with how these cameras may activate in specific circumstances, originating from the same 2019 upgrade.
National Highways’ modelling of data has concluded that the probability of the specific operational circumstances that could result in this error occurring is no more than 0.1%, and there is no real-world evidence to suggest it has impacted enforcement.
The government holds itself to the highest standards of criminal proof and in the protection of road safety. Ministers are not prepared to accept any scenario where there is a hypothetical risk some drivers could be prosecuted incorrectly, or that enforcement was in any way compromised.
The Home Office has decided to revoke the camera system’s type approval status, which allows the data from the camera to be more easily admitted as evidence of fact into certain legal proceedings. The Home Office concluded that the issues with the camera could not be addressed to their satisfaction in any reasonable timeframe.
The camera system was procured by National Highways on the basis that it maintained its Home Office type approval. Since that is no longer the case, National Highways is ending its contractual relationship to use the cameras for enforcement with the device supplier, Verra Mobility, and is considering all further commercial and legal options that may be appropriate.
Throughout this process, enforcement has been conducted through a range of different tactics and this remains in place on all motorways and A roads. National Highways monitoring through focused traffic officer patrols and data collection has assured that compliance with the law remains at the usual high levels on these roads, which remain safe.
However, we are taking immediate steps to ensure compliance is maintained at relevant locations. National Highways has today put in place further traffic officer service patrols to monitor these sites and is using existing CCTV cameras to assist with monitoring the network and compliance. This is in addition to existing safety measures like the stopped vehicle detection radars on sections of all lane running and emergency areas, and the use of existing ANPR cameras, to identify offenders.
Variable speed signage will continue to be used to manage safety, control traffic flow and reduce congestion.
I want to reiterate that this issue affects a very small number of cameras on a limited proportion of the strategic road network. Drivers will see no difference in the way they use roads. Safety remains our overriding priority and the additional steps we are taking to implement enforcement arrangements will ensure action can be taken against anyone who breaks the law.
In short: if you break the law you should expect to be subject to enforcement action.
We are also today (17 November 2026) publishing the Westall Review report, which examines how the original technical anomaly occurred and how it was subsequently handled after its discovery. The review identifies key lessons for National Highways relating to corporate governance, crisis management processes, data and technology management and stakeholder engagement.
The government welcomes the report and accepts the recommendations it contains, and I would like to thank Tracy Westall for her thoroughness and dedication in conducting the review.
National Highways has also accepted the review’s recommendations and has already begun to implement the improvements needed, building on steps already taken.
My department will monitor National Highways’ progress in implementing the recommendations and hold it accountable through our existing sponsorship arrangements.